The New York Times Book Review
September 7, 2003
Crime By Marilyn Stasio
|
The fluffy tone of Little Indiscretions
(Random House, $23.95), which won Spain’s Planeta Prize for
Carmen Posadas in 1998, is just the melt-in-your-mouth frosting
on an otherwise tart -- and surprisingly substantial -- comic mystery
about the perils of gossip. When the body of Nestor Chaffino, a
pastry chef ‘‘renowned for his masterful way with a
chocolate fondant,’’ is discovered in the freezer of
the estate on the Costa del Sol where his company is catering a
dinner, everyone gives up a shout: ‘‘Thank God for household
accidents!’’ But was it really an accident? It seems
as if Nestor was writing an expose of his rich clients’ foibles,
some of them well worth the price of murder to suppress. Posadas’s
whimsical style, which holds its humor in Christopher Andrews’s
airy translation from the Spanish, gives her story the charms of
any lightweight whodunit. But her characters’ secrets are
truly dark, and the irony is heavier than any souffle that Nestor
would ever whip up.
 |
 |
The Washington Post Book
World
August 31, 2003
Reviewed by Katy Munger
Truffles Are My Business
|
Once in a while, a book comes
along that is sheer delight. Such is Little Indiscretions, by Carmen
Posadas, translated from the Spanish by Christopher Andrews (Random
House, $23.95). Winner of Spain’s Planeta Prize, this slender
novel has it all: an elegant setting, a taut time frame, a cast
of intriguing characters and beautifully crafted writing that lends
both glamour and insight to the tale.
The story begins late at night when chef Nestor Chaffinno wraps
up a successful dinner party by storing his beloved truffles in
the client’s walk-in freezer. Without warning, the door clicks
shut behind him, condemning him to a slow and very cold death. As
he thinks back over the weeks preceding his murder, we learn that
this meticulously mannered chef knows many secrets, both about exquisite
cooking and the lives of the dinner guests. His thoughts supply
a lively backdrop for the story that follows, introducing characters
and motivations.
Posadas then takes us into the heads of each of the main suspects.
We meet Nestor’s assistant, a Czech body builder who is sometimes
perplexed by but always accepting of the strange ways of Western
Europe; a well-respected judge whose wife has recently died, pitching
him into the path of a temptation he thought he had beaten decades
ago; a successful art dealer whose current respectability masks
a shady past involving Argentina’s nastiest political era;
a spoiled little rich girl who thinks that multiple body piercings
will help erase the pain of her brother’s too-early death;
and an aging society beauty whose icy control of her world is threatening
to melt in the face of an unexpected, forbidden love. The characters
in turn reveal their pasts, their dreams, their transgressions and
their fears layer by layer as the book moves steadily toward its
climax. Posadas never makes a misstep with these characters, despite
wide disparities in their ages and backgrounds.
Best of all, the story is set against a slightly exaggerated, sensual
Madrid, a place where fortune tellers possess real powers of prophecy,
wear tiny brocaded slippers fit for an empress and have faces that
seem to shift in shape; where nightclubs close at 3 a.m., then open
back up again in minutes, transformed for a mysterious, nocturnal
crowd; where love of any persuasion can be satisfied behind closed
doors for the right price; and, most of all, a place were secrets
kept for years have a way of coming out in the end.
The finale of the book makes this abundantly clear. The chef’s
murder emerges as ironic, and the solution seems deceptively simple
-- until the reader slowly realizes its implications. You may find
yourself closing the book to conduct a mental inventory of your
past sins as you are forced to acknowledge that secrets have a way
of betraying even those who resolutely keep them.
Special mention must be made of the book’s translator, Christopher
Andrews, for preserving the cadences of Posadas’s prose without
sacrificing her rich nuances.
Katy Munger is working on her 10th crime novel.
 |
 |
PUBLISHER’S WEEKLY
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.
|
The death of a manipulative,
mischievous pastry chef sets the stage for this insouciant whodunit,
with its humorous and philosophical narrative voice, from Spanish
author Carmen Posadas. When the frozen body of Nestor Chaffino,
who had been hired to cater a party at art dealer Ernesto Teldi’s
Costa del Sol summer house, turns up in the kitchen “cool
room” the morning of the party, the evidence, including a
nonworking alarm button in the freezer, points to murder. And why
was the victim clutching a scrap of paper with a fragmentary list
of dessert recipes? In a series of flashbacks, the author adroitly
lays out the “little indiscretions,” adulterous and
otherwise (recorded by the conniving Nestor in his moleskin notebook),
that bind Ernesto, his wife, a naïve young Czech kitchen helper,
a renegade waitress, a widowed judge and various other distinctive
and unusual characters. The action proceeds with all the inevitability
of a Greek tragedy to a denouement both hilarious and horrifying.
(Aug. 19)
Little Indiscretions won the 1998 Planeta Prize, topped bestseller
lists and sold more than half a million copies in Spain. Born in
Uruguay, the author now lives in Madrid.
 |
 |
LIBRARY JOURNAL
Shelley Mosley, Glendale P.L., AZ
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information
|
Famous pastry chef Nestor Chaffino
would still be alive if he’d stuck to writing recipes and
cooking hints in his pristine little ?notebook. But he didn’t,
so someone locked him in cold storage with his chocolate truffles.
Whodunit? Any one of the quirky characters could have killed the
keeper of secrets, both culinary and personal-the odd but omniscient
clairvoyant; Nestor’s Czech body-building assistant; his young
helper; the man with the old-fashioned military crew cut; or even
the owner of the house where Nestor was frozen alive. This is murder
spiced with humor, stirred with a light touch, and served up in
a deft translation. Originally published in Spain as Pequeñas
Infamias, this book won top honors with the Planeta Award for literature
in 1998. This is an excellent addition in both English and Spanish
for libraries of all sizes. The author, who has won prizes for her
children’s books, also writes for film and television and
lives in Madrid.
 |
 |
A secret-hoarding caterer is
frozen to death inside a wealthy client’s walk-in freezer:
an English-translation debut that sounds like, but emphatically
isn’t, a case for Hercule Poirot. Nor for any other fictional
detective either, since children’s author Posadas begins her
story with its ending: The night peerless pastry cook Nestor Chaffino’s
natural buoyancy turns to peevishness and finally terror when he
finds himself locked inside the cold room at the Lilies, Ernesto
Teldi’s house on the Costa del Sol. Instead of unleashing
a sleuth, Posadas charts the gravely wacky incidents that led up
to Nestor’s final frozen dessert and the secrets he collected
along with his prized recipes. Which of them led to his murder?
Was it something he knew about the checkered career of Ernesto Teldi
before he settled into the safe groove of an art dealer? Or about
the suicide years ago of Adela Teldi’s sister Soledad during
an intimate visit to her sister and her brother-in-law? Or about
the motorcycle death years before that of Eddie Trias, whose grieving
sister Chloe survived to become Nestor’s unpaid kitchen hand
and his waiter Carlos Garcia’s lover? Or about the incorrigible
fondness Ernesto’s friend, the magistrate Serafin Tous, has
for beautiful young men? Or about the clairvoyant Madame Longstaffe’s
advice to Carlos about how to find his love and her prediction that
Nestor didn’t have to worry about the lung cancer he was convinced
would kill him? It all sounds very mysterious, but Posadas is writing
a pastiche rather than a whodunit, beginning with the twist that
the “little indiscretions” Nestor prizes so highly really
are cooking secrets rather than his friends’ dirty laundry.
Arch concept humor, deliberately paced yet weirdly discordant—exactly
the sort of thing that will appeal to readers who like that sort
of thing, as half a million readers in 12 languages reportedly have
so far.
 |
 |
Booklist
GraceAnne DeCandido
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights
reserved
|
This elegant mystery, which won
the 1998 Planeta Prize in Barcelona, has as many secrets as one
of the murder victim’s chocolate fondants. Nestor, a pastry
chef with a penchant for other people’s hidden desires, freezes
to death in the walk-in cold room where he has just catered a party
for Ernesto Teldi, an art collector on the Costa del Sol. Ernesto,
his wife, Adela, Nestor’s twisted young employee Chloe, and
Serafin, an old friend of the Teldis, all have secrets that Nestor
has discovered. His appearance at the party causes much fear and
loathing--but who locks that freezer door? Serpentine sentences
about childhood memories and furtive desires wrestle with verbal
flourishes as light as a random caress. Utterly European in its
aristocratic air, and great fun to read even though Nestor’s
recipes are tantalizingly incomplete.
|